On April 14, 2008 Phoenix faced Mickie James with her Women's Championship on the line and lost, ending her reign as champion.
Their second daughter, named Ruby Ever Copeland, was born on May 31, 2016.
Kociański attended in Elmira, where she played and ran.
Kociański credits this as when she fell in love with.
Phoenix challenged Kelly for the Divas Championship again at , but was unsuccessful.
Her induction made her the quickest female to be inducted after her retirement, as she had retired only five years prior, and made her and her husband the first real-life couple to both be inducted.