While his replacement Christian Tosi acquitted herself well, fans felt let down by the casting shakeup and took a while to get used to it.
Fred, Sam, and Liz were declared as having the worst dishes while Evan, Michael, Shari, Nick, Bri, and Wuta were called to the front for having the best dishes of the night.
The bottom three dishes belong to Annai, Matt, and Abe.
Even after his departure from the American version of the cooking competition, Bastianich wasn't quite willing to leave his place behind the judging booth.
With Autumn, viewers were less interested in her cooking and more curious about how she broke her foot and why her Boston accent faded as the season progressed via.
The contestants randomly draw numbered candles to pick a cake of their choice.